Best of NYC

I can’t tell you how many times I get asked what my favorite spots in NYC are, so I figured I’d round them up all in one place. While NYC has no shortage of great establishments, these are my absolute top picks. In addition to having great food (and drinks) these spots also have great atmospheres and service. I’ll be sure to update this page regularly!

(More notable restaurants listed here)

Eats

Upland
Upland covers all the bases and is great for just about every occasion. Favorite dishes: the Upland Burger (brunch only), Estrella, Whole Crispy Mushroom. Read more of my review here.

Rebelle
Great for a special occasion. Extensive wine menu, and I’m slightly obsessed with their marble bar. On Sundays for brunch they have live music and 1/2 off all wines under $400. Favorite dishes: Cured Fluke, Roast Duck, Pain Perdu (brunch), Egg Sandwich (brunch), Cocoa & Marshmallow dessert.

Cosme
Cosme was one of those places I was concerned might be all hype (don’t ask me why), but it turned out to be one of the best meals I’ve had in NYC. Their service could use some work, and their barstools are abnormally tall (you’ll see what I mean), but the incredible food more than makes up for it. Their Duck Carnitas and Husk Meringue with Corn Mousse dessert are not just favorites – they are an absolute must.

Quality Eats
A cozy addition to the Quality Branded restaurants, tucked away in the West Village. Delicious and inventive comfort food + great cocktails. Favorite dishes: Grilled Nueske’s Bacon, Brown-Bag Curly Fries, Creamed Spinach Hush Puppies, Grilled Octopus, Baked Potato Monkey Bread, The Don Ameche Steak, Scoops. Read more of my review here

Tacombi
There’s a very special place in my heart for Tacombi, and it’s probably my most frequented spot in the city (just about once a week, but whose counting?). They have 4 locations in the city, but my favorite is Nolita followed by Flatiron. Favorite dishes: Chips and Guac, Crispy Fish Taco, Carnitas Tacos.

L’Artusi
There’s a reason it’s still an NYC favorite after so many years. To me, L’Artusi is the epitome of the perfect West Village restaurant. It’s understated and small with a hint of chic, but the service and food are top notch. You can’t go wrong with anything on the menu here, but you probably want to focus on the pastas. My favorite dishes are the Roasted Mushrooms, Garganelli, and Bucatini. Leave room for dessert because the Olive Oil Cake, Banana Rum Semifreddo and Hazelnut Chocolate Torta are far from “afterthought” desserts.

The Polo Bar
The Polo Bar is all about the experience, from the moment you make the reservation (must call and only 2 weeks in advance) to stepping into the bar (only available for those with reservations), to walking downstairs to the dining area, which feels like you’re entering an exclusive members-only club. The food is quite good, but not necessarily anything to write home about. One of the few places where the experience trumps all.

Avra
Avra (Madison location) is unlike most NYC restaurants I’ve been to, which is why I love it. It’s a beautiful huge space and very white/bright – Grecian inspired. Great for large groups and special occasions. Favorite dishes: Greek Salad, Calamari, Grilled Octopus, Lobster, Chilean Sea Bass.

Emilio’s Ballato
In a sea of inventive, “fusion” restaurants, Emilio’s Ballato is a traditional Italian restaurant that knows exactly what it’s doing (as in, they don’t even have or appear to need a website). They have incredible service and even better authentic Italian food. You can’t really go wrong with your order, but definitely don’t skip the Tagliatelle alla Bolognese.

Bowery Meat Company
For when you’re feeling extra carnivorous. I’ve also noticed a constant abundance of handsome men in suits, if you’re into that sort of thing. Favorite dishes: Wagyu Meatballs, Chinese BBQ Pork Belly, New York Strip Steak, Duck Lasagna. 

Baby Bo’s Cantina
A favorite “hole in the wall” restaurant, and one of my only excuses to go to Murray Hill. Some of the most authentic Mexican food I’ve had in the city.

Hudson Clearwater
Another favorite spot tucked away in the West Village. I love going with a friend or two and eating at the small bar. They change their menu (slightly) quite often, but I’ve never had a bad dish there. Favorite dishes: Sage & Ricotta Gnocchi, Duck Breast, Hanger Steak, Brussels Sprouts. 

Freemans
Freemans is the ultimate cozy brunch spot hidden in a back alley in the LES with colonial/rustic American inspiration. I can’t say I’ve ever been for dinner, but their brunch musts are: House-made Granola, Buttermilk Biscuit Sandwich, Burger, Cheese Grits.

Levain Bakery
There’s a 99% chance you’ll have to wait in line for the world’s best chocolate chip cookie, but it’s worth every second.

Rubirosa
Some of the most famous pizza in New York, and for good reason. Expect to wait a bit (always crowded), but it’s worth it. I actually prefer eating at the bar. Get the Rubirosa Supreme. 

Scarpetta
A crowd-pleaser that you can suggest to just about anyone. Favorite dishes: Yellowtail, Braised Short Ribs, Short Rib & Bone Marrow Agnolotti, Spaghetti, Espresso Budino dessert.

Laconda Verde
Another all-around favorite, similarly to Upland. A lovely atmosphere with equally great food for both brunch and dinner. Beautiful bar as well.

American Cut
A classic steakhouse with a modern twist. I’m partial to the Tribeca location. MUST try the Everything Biscuits. Check out all of my favorite dishes in this review.

The Clocktower
The EDITION New York can do no wrong in my book, and The Clocktower is no exception. An exceptional dining experience – great for a special occasion. Favorite dishes: Beef Tartare, Long Island Duck, Macaroni and Cheese.

Bubby’s
Bubby’s is all about the comfort food – don’t go here when you’re trying to eat light. They have great dinner (Chicken & Waffles, anyone?) but I’m partial to their brunch. I love eating at the bar at the Highline location.

Oficina 1M
A new favorite tucked away in Nolita with a vintage-chic atmosphere and an inventive take on Italian food. I instantly formed a weird obsession with their table settings and china (you’ll see). You MUST order the Taglioni (which comes literally wrapped in prosciutto) and the Gnocchi Di Ceci.

Two Hands Restaurant
I had visited their original cafe years prior and was mildly impressed, but I instantly fell in love with the newer Two Hands Restaurant. It’s larger, brighter, and very California-esque. A great spot for breakfast or lunch with friends, or even solo. All of the food I’ve tried there is delicious (their Smashed Avocado is a classic), but the Banana Bread with Espresso Mascarpone is out of this world. 

Momoya
Two words: Crispy Rice. Momoya is where I first discovered the “sushi” favorite that rocked my world, so it holds a special place in my heart. The rest of their menu is full of 
inventive (and classic) sushi that is always incrediblly fresh. 

Koi
My other favorite sushi spot…coincidentally also primarily based on there Crispy Rice. Also a favorite – the “She’s So LA” Roll.

ABC Cocina
Not usually as popular as its sister ABC Kitchen, I’m partial to ABC Cocina and their Latin American small plates. The tacos are the standout menu items for me (no surprise there), especially the Savory Glazed Short Rib Tacos.  

Magnolia Bakery
…and their Banana Pudding. Enough said. Probably my favorite dessert on the planet.

Blake Lane
Hu Kitchen
Marc Forgione
Out East
Prince St Pizza

After Eats

A solid mix of chic hotel bars, trendy (yet chill) bars, and lounges/nightclubs. Take your pick.

Rose Bar
Cafe Carlyle

Palm Court at The Plaza
The Bar at Baccarat Hotel
New York EDITION Lobby Bar
The Blond
The Garett East
Dear Irving
The Happiest Hour
The Library at the NoMad
Up & Down
310 Bowery Bar
Freehold
PDT
205 Club
The Other Room
Jia Lounge
The Elephant Bar
Macao Trading Co.
The Daily
The Black Lodge
Employee’s Only
Acme
La Esquina
Tijuana Picnic
The Ship
Apotheke
The Mulberry Project
Los Feliz
Tiki Tabu
The VNYL
The Wren
No Fun
Suffolk Arms
Garfunkel’s
The Flower Shop
Paul’s Casablanca
The Lately
Kind Regards
Bar Fortuna

 

 

Caffeinate 

Stumptown Coffee at Ace Hotel
La Colombe
Bluestone Lane
Saturdays Surf
Grey Dog
Kaffe 1668
FIKA

Hamptons

Guide to Montauk